The Law Offices of Jacqueline Goodman

Free Consultations & Flexible Payment Plans |

Super Lawyers

New Ruling Makes Circumstantial Evidence in DUI Cases Permissible

Posted By The Law Offices of Jacqueline Goodman || 8-May-2015

The denial of a DMV hearing appeal could lead to legal recognition of circumstantial evidence in DUI cases and expert testimony in future administrative hearings. An Orange County woman who agreed to a plea deal to admit to misdemeanor reckless driving attempted to challenge her driver's license suspension at a DMV hearing. The woman hired an expert who argued that her blood alcohol level was under the legal limit when she was stopped and arrested but rose later while she was in police custody.

The defendant had been arrested in 2011 when police observed her swerving on the freeway and suspected she was intoxicated based on observing her red eyes, the scent of alcohol coming from her car, and her difficulty in performing field sobriety tests.

The DMV hearing officer rejected the expert's testimony, saying the police officer's suspicions were valid. The California Supreme Court agreed although they noted that the opinion of the expert should not have been thrown out but considered.

The defendant's attorney, Chad Maddox, remarked that the case did set some guidelines as far as future DUI defense cases which take circumstantial evidence is considered and chemical test are inconclusive. Attorney Maddox did express fear that "the ruling, however, could grant greater weight to circumstantial evidence such as a heavy odor of alcohol."

A DUI arrest can ruin your life so retain a dedicated Orange County criminal defense attorney to contest your charges and build you a redoubtable defense. Call Attorney Jacqueline Goodmantoday!

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

We Have An Exceptional Track Record

Possession of burglary tools:Case Dismissed

case results
Email Us For Response

Get Your Free Consultation

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

The Law Offices of Jacqueline Goodman
712 N Harbor Blvd
Fullerton, CA 92832

Toll Free: 866-287-6930
Fax: 714-879-5771
Map & Directions

contact us